East Carolina Collectibles was born from a simple idea shared by three friends from Eastern North Carolina — that the things we grew up loving deserve a place to live on. We grew up trading baseball cards at recess, reading comics on summer afternoons, and hunting yard sales for that one toy we always wanted. That passion never left us.
So we did something about it. We opened our doors right here in the heart of downtown Robersonville to create the kind of shop we always wished existed — a place where collectors feel at home, where every item has a story, and where the person behind the counter actually knows what they're talking about.
Whether you're a seasoned collector chasing a grail, a newcomer just getting started, or someone sitting on a collection you're ready to pass along — we're your people. Come in, browse, swap stories, and let's talk collectibles.
Why Choose Us
Eastern NC's Most Trusted Buyers
We're collectors ourselves — so we know what your items are worth and we pay accordingly. No low-ball offers, no runaround.
Collectors drive from Greenville, Rocky Mount, New Bern, Goldsboro, Wilmington, Raleigh, Wilson, Farmville, Plymouth, Edenton, and all across North Carolina to sell to us — and they say it's worth the trip.
01
Fair Market Prices
We research current market values before every offer. You'll know your collection is being evaluated by someone who truly understands what it's worth.
02
Same-Day Payment
No waiting weeks for an online auction to close. Bring your items in and walk out with payment the same day. It's that simple.
03
Collections Large & Small
One comic book or a thousand — a single card or an entire estate. We're interested in everything from single key issues to complete collections.
04
Local & Trusted
We're your neighbors in Eastern NC. Our reputation in the community is everything to us — expect honest, respectful service every time.
05
No Appointment Needed
Just walk in. Bring your items and we'll take a look right away. We keep the process easy and hassle-free for every seller.
06
We Make House Calls
Have a large collection you can't haul in? We come to you. Contact us and we'll arrange a visit — no hauling required.
We Buy & Sell
Browse Our Categories
From golden-age comics to modern Pokémon sets, vintage tin toys to rare coins, military memorabilia to vinyl records — we stock and seek the full spectrum.
⚾
Baseball Cards
Vintage Topps to modern hits. All eras, all grades — raw and graded.
Bags, boards, boxes, binders, top-loaders, sleeves — everything to protect your collection.
Vintage Toys We're Actively Buying
Toy Lines We Want!
Got figures, vehicles, playsets, or accessories from any of these lines? We want to buy them — carded, loose, complete or not. Bring 'em in!
Advanced Dungeons & DragonsAir RaidersAliensA-TeamBarbieBatmanBattle of the PlanetsBattlestar GalacticaBionic SixBlack HoleBlackstarBone AgeBravestarrBuck RogersBugmen of InsectaCaptain PowerCenturionsChuck Norris Karate KommandosClash of the TitansComic Action HeroesConanC.O.P.S.CrystarDefenders of the EarthDino RidersDoctor WhoDragonriders of the StyxDroidsDukes of HazzardDuneEarth ForceEwoksFlash GordonGalaxy FightersGalaxy WarriorsGhostbustersGI JoeGoBotsGremlinsHot WheelsIndiana JonesInhumanoidsKnight RiderLEGOLord of the RingsM.A.S.K.Marvel LegendsMasters of the UniverseMicro MachinesMicronautsMy Little PonyPower LordsPredatorPrincess of PowerRainbow BriteRamboRobo ForceRobotechRock LordsSecret WarsSectaursShe-RaShogun WarriorsSilverhawksStarcomStar TrekStar WarsSuper PowersTerminatorThundercatsTransformersTronVisionariesVoltronX-MenZoids
Don't see your line listed? Bring it in anyway — this list isn't exhaustive and we love surprises!
Simple Process
How to Sell Us Your Collection
Four easy steps from attic to payment. No appointments, no sending photos, no waiting.
1
Gather Your Items
Round up what you'd like to sell. Comics, cards, toys, coins — anything you think has value. Don't worry about sorting ahead of time.
2
Bring Them In
Visit us at 101 S Main St in Robersonville. No appointment needed. Walk-ins always welcome during business hours.
3
We Evaluate
Our knowledgeable staff will review your items on-the-spot and give you a fair, no-pressure offer based on real market values.
4
Get Paid
Accept our offer and receive same-day payment — we settle up right then and there. The easiest way to convert your collection into money in Eastern NC.
Everything you need to know before you bring your collection in.
Pretty much anything collectible — baseball cards, sports cards, comic books, Pokémon, video games, vintage toys, action figures, vinyl records, gold & silver, jewelry, watches, coins, military items, knives, Zippo lighters, magazines, band t-shirts, NASCAR T-Shirts & Hats, diecast cars, non-sport cards, local history items, yearbooks, class rings, license plates & tags, and more. When in doubt, bring it in.
No appointment needed — ever. Just walk in during store hours and we'll take a look at your items right then and there. No waiting, no scheduling, no hassle.
Yes. Condition matters but it doesn't disqualify your items. We buy comics and cards in all grades, toys that are loose or missing pieces, and collections that are mixed or unsorted. Bring it in and let us take a look — you may be surprised what has value.
We look at current market values using real recent sales data — not guesses. We factor in condition, demand, and what items are actually selling for right now. We're collectors ourselves, so we know the market and we make fair offers that reflect it.
Same day, right there in the shop. Accept our offer and you walk out with payment — no waiting on checks to clear, no consignment delays, no following up later.
Yes — gold and silver bullion, coins, estate jewelry, watches, and precious metal items of all kinds. We pay competitive rates based on current market prices.
Absolutely. We buy medals, uniforms, insignia, paperwork, letters, knives, watches, and memorabilia from all eras and branches of service. We serve collectors and veterans near Camp Lejeune, Seymour Johnson AFB, and MCAS Cherry Point — military collectibles are a specialty of ours.
Follow us on Facebook — we post new inventory regularly so you can check out what's in the shop from home. You can also call us at (252) 284-3015 or just stop in.
Yes — we serve the entire eastern half of North Carolina. Customers come from Raleigh, Greenville, Rocky Mount, Wilson, Goldsboro, Kinston, Jacksonville, New Bern, Tarboro, Washington NC, and surrounding counties every week. If you're within a few hours of Robersonville, it's worth the trip.
Google Reviews
What Our Customers Say
★★★★★4.9 out of 5 · Google Reviews
★★★★★
"Large selection of collectibles and Larry was very friendly and quite knowledgeable. My father, also a collector and seller, had a great visit. The store is breathing life into the downtown area. A great and interesting place to visit, collector or not."
— Debbie Calkins · Local Guide
★★★★★
"Drove a ways to get there — went in looking for comics and records and was amazed at the whole store. Classic toys and games, thousands of comics, coins, records, and lots of unique stuff. The owners were helpful, knew their stuff, and easy to talk to. Worth the drive."
— Justin Nale
★★★★★
"Awesome gem of a place! I am from Florida and have been there twice. I have spent hours going through the over 3,000 square feet of collectibles of all types from vintage comics, cards, toys, and video games. Got some treasures from this place at great prices!"
Collectors across the entire eastern half of North Carolina trust us to buy and sell. Whether you're cleaning out an estate in Raleigh, liquidating a collection in Greenville, or just passing through on 64 — we're right here for you.
Located on Main Street in Robersonville — centrally positioned to serve collectors across the entire eastern half of North Carolina. We see customers from Wake, Johnston, Nash, Halifax, Edgecombe, Wilson, Pitt, Martin, Beaufort, Bertie, Hertford, Northampton, Warren, Franklin, Lenoir, Wayne, Greene, Duplin, Craven, Onslow, Carteret, Jones, Pamlico, Tyrrell, Washington, Dare, Hyde, Currituck, Camden, Pasquotank, Perquimans, Chowan, and Gates counties every week. We proudly serve veterans and collectors near Camp Lejeune, Seymour Johnson AFB, and MCAS Cherry Point.
